52 Comments
User's avatar
Betina Cunado's avatar

I totally get you! When I was living in Paris, a pigeon used to visit me every day at the same time. I never named her, but I waited for her each day, and she never missed a visit. Honestly, the hardest part about leaving Paris for Barcelona was knowing I was leaving her at the mercy of the new tenant, who probably wouldn’t welcome her the way I did. It’s been a year, and I still think about her.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Oh, Betina! You really get it. That’s lovely. A fellow pigeon-lover! ❤️🕊️

Expand full comment
Betina Cunado's avatar

Yes! We became friends...

Expand full comment
Linda Kriss's avatar

I so enjoy your writing, Gregory.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Linda! That's wonderful to hear.

Expand full comment
Kaarin Marx Smith's avatar

Such a lovely, poignant post. You evoked such tenderness for Clarissa and also for your relationship with Liza. And of course, I can't help thinking of the line, "If you love something (someone) let her go..." Clarissa helped you do that with so much grace.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Kaarin. I so pleased that the piece resonated with you. 🙏

Expand full comment
Gwendolyn Pierce's avatar

Beautiful piece. Thank you so much for reposting. 💜

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Gwendolyn!

Expand full comment
Fernando's avatar

Another lovely short-story. Você é um contista e cronista nato, Gregory! Sim, já lhe disse isso em outra oportunidade 😊.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Muito obrigado, querido amigo! Sabe bem poder partilhar os meus textos com outros. Especialmente se eles gostarem!

Expand full comment
Alma Earthling's avatar

A kindred soul. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you! 🙏

Expand full comment
Dearbhla Kelly M.A.'s avatar

Beautiful 🐦

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you. 🐥

Expand full comment
Linnéa's avatar

I still love this piece.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

That's a comfort, since it hasn't changed. ;) But seriously, thank you.

Expand full comment
Linnéa's avatar

Ever unwavering, me.

Expand full comment
SK's avatar

This is beautiful! Thank you for sharing.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you!

Expand full comment
Judith Mansour's avatar

You are a special person who can see through beyond the pain to learn something. Maybe someday I will learn the same. Thanks for sharing.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Judith. I also hope that you will.

Expand full comment
Karen Gordon's avatar

“Drafting and leaving behind a white paper on optimal human-pigeon relations was clearly a non-starter.” This is a **hilarious** line in the midst of such a poignant loss. I love it. Beautiful writing. The most vulnerable essays are usually the most impactful. Glad you reposted it.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Karen. I was hoping that that line would speak to somebody. I'm glad you enjoyed the piece.

Expand full comment
Karen Gordon's avatar

humor is the highest form of intelligence!

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Pity it didn’t get me into MIT…

Expand full comment
N. Duffey's avatar

Beautiful.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you.

Expand full comment
Clarice Dankers's avatar

This was a lovely, heartfelt piece, Gregory. Thank you for being willing to share it with us.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thank you, Clarice!

Expand full comment
Brynn's avatar

My partner and I live in Lisbon and share a similar journey to yourself Gregory. Only difference is I prefer the Seagulls and my partner prefers the Pigeons.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

I hear you, Brynn. I recently moved from that pigeon-centric apartment to a more seagull-centric one closer to the river, and I can see that both types of birds have their annoying habits and their charms. Luckily, you don't have to choose, do you?

Expand full comment
Brynn's avatar

Funny you say that, Gregory. Being close to the river, I’ve also discovered a new avian friend—the Peregrine Falcon. You’ll notice they have leather straps on them, as they’re used to control pigeon and seagull populations, especially in tourist-heavy areas.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Oh! I have a falcon near my house, but I'm pretty sure she is strapless. I think she lives in the local tower, and I'm not sure what she controls. I have to say that, as much as I admire falcons, I'm not keen on the thought of one eating Clarissa!

Maybe if the tourists get out of hand, we will start to see tigers with leather straps running around?

Expand full comment
Brynn's avatar

Makes complete sense! I’m sure as summer approaches, we’ll see a few tigers brought in to manage the cruise ship populations docking by the river. I don’t know about you, Gregory, but I do love a good black panther sighting.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

If you see any panthers downtown, do let me know!

Expand full comment
Sally's avatar

As a fellow pigeon-observer and sometime pigeon-landlady, I love this piece. I spent last Spring and Summer watching the travails of a pair of pigeons nest-building and squab-raising in my wisteria tree, and was somewhat bereft when the babies fled the nest and Harold and Maud (pigeon parents) eventually left too. All winter, the leafless wisteria has sat bare, the nest empty, and eventually cannibalised by various sparrows, until now, only a few twigs remain.

I consulted Pigeonpedia a lot (yes, Pigeonpedia is a thing) which told me that pigeons mate for life, that they return to the same nest each year, and that they actually recognise people. I'm hoping Harold and Maud will return this Spring to rebuild Nest BnB and raise another two squabs, and maybe even recognise me.

All this is to say that I hear you completely, and I too stare at random pigeons wondering whether they are 'mine'.

Just as importantly, I wish you and Liza all the best in your loving separation, and your individual futures - wherever you may fly.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Sally, who knew that Pigeonpedia existed! You are opening up whole new worlds for me. I love the thought that pigeons recognize people.

I hope that Harold and Maud (are they the same age or not?) will return and provide you with more edification, and not leave the wisteria too wistful.

And thank you for your kind words to Liza and me. It's difficult, but we are trying to figure it out. Happily, we are both roosting in Lisbon for the foreseeable future.

Expand full comment
Renata Lins's avatar

Hey, Gregory, I didn't dream, you wrote about Clarissa before, didn't you?

This is such a lovely story, thanks for sharing. Really sweet of Liza to text you to ask about her. Little things.

(Clarissa is my sister-in-law's name, as well as one of my cousins. Thinking of sharing your text with them :-) ).

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Hi Renata! If you got an email with this text, you will see there a note explaining that I am republishing my favorite piece from the past six months (this one). So yes, it's an old text, with some new pictures.

And either you have a big family, or there is a connection between me and them—I'm thinking also of your cousin Elizabeth. Please feel free to share whatever you like. (Not your cousin, though—I know she's married. ;) )

Expand full comment
Renata Lins's avatar

oh, sorry, I opened it directly on substack, not via e-mail. and I wasn’t quite sure it was the same text, I only remembered the story.

I do have a big family… lots of names to match yet. :-))))

If you have connections to a Gloria or an Antonio, Gloria was my grandmother + three of my cousins (Glorita, Gloritinha and Gloricita); Antonio comes from my great-grandfather, to my grandfather, my uncle, my cousin and… my nephew.

“Clarissa” is a great piece indeed.

Expand full comment
Gregory Garretson's avatar

Thanks, Renata! I will hang on to Goritinha and Antonio as possible names for my next avian friends.

Expand full comment